The Mindful Tourist Nature-Based Intervention, Mindfulness & Wellbeing
The Mindful Tourist

We Are Updating Our Website

We are currently updating The Mindful Tourist website, including pages, articles and resources dating back to 2021.

Bringing everything up to date will take some time. During this process, certain pages and links may not yet work as expected.

We sincerely apologise for any inconvenience. You are warmly invited to continue exploring the website and the content already available.

Thank you for your patience and understanding.

Q&A with Milena — Follow-up Part 5: Nature, Culture and Ethics. Are We Respecting Nature, or Are We Still Trying to Make Nature Serve Us?

The Mindful Tourist® | Q&A with Milena

Nature, Culture
& Ethics

Follow-up Part 5 · Questions 11–14

Shinrin-Yoku · Forest Bathing · Forest Therapy

Milena A. Guziak, MChem, PhDEng, MScPsy

In this fifth part of our Q&A series, I explore four questions connecting the cultural history of Shinrin-Yoku, ecological responsibility, human wellbeing and nature connectedness.

These reflections draw upon my research published in the Shinrin-Yoku Journal, professional experience and the educational approach developed through The Mindful Tourist®.

How do we respect nature not only through our intentions, but also through our knowledge, professional decisions and everyday actions?

Four Questions. One Shared Responsibility.

A visual summary of the themes explored in this part of our Q&A.

QUESTION 11

Culture & History

Recognise Japan's contribution to Shinrin-Yoku while acknowledging wider human and scientific histories.

QUESTION 12

Ecological Responsibility

Evaluate benefits and harms for guides, participants and natural environments over different timescales.

QUESTION 13

The Reality of Nature

Recognise that nature includes restoration and beauty, but also risk, discomfort and unpredictability.

QUESTION 14

Connection & Recognition

Explore whether reconnection means restoring a lost relationship or becoming conscious of one that already exists.

Toward Responsible Nature Engagement

Historical understanding · Ethical practice · Ecological care · Conscious relationship

Question 11 · Culture and History

Are We Respecting the Japanese Origins of Shinrin-Yoku?

How can we acknowledge Japan's cultural and scientific contributions without misrepresenting the history of human relationships with nature?

11.1 · A Modern Term Within a Much Older History

Shinrin-Yoku was introduced as a modern Japanese concept through the Forestry Agency in 1982.

However, the introduction of a term does not mean that the underlying experience began at that moment.

Human relationships with forests extend across evolutionary and cultural history.

People have interacted with natural environments through survival, observation, agriculture, spirituality, recreation and scientific inquiry.

We should therefore distinguish the origin of the modern term from the much older experience of being within a forest.

A scientific or professional name may change how an experience is understood, but it does not create the underlying human–nature encounter.
11.2 · Shinto, Sacred Forests and Modern Shinrin-Yoku

A frequent misunderstanding is that Shinrin-Yoku is an ancient Shinto ritual.

This is not an accurate account of its modern origin.

Shinto traditions include complex relationships with kami, sacred places, shrines and natural environments.

Chinju no mori, the sacred groves associated with shrines, may hold religious, cultural, historical and ecological meaning.

These older traditions deserve recognition, but they are not interchangeable with the 1982 Forestry Agency initiative.

Cultural respect involves understanding the distinctions rather than presenting all Japanese relationships with forests as one practice.

11.3 · Giving Credit to Scientific Contributors

The scientific development of forest-related health research involved numerous contributions.

Boris Petrovich Tokin's twentieth-century investigations of phytoncides preceded the modern Shinrin-Yoku initiative.

The Japanese Forestry Agency introduced Shinrin-Yoku in 1982.

Yoshifumi Miyazaki and colleagues contributed significantly to physiological investigations of forest environments.

Other researchers expanded the field through studies of immune function, stress responses, psychology and ecology.

Iwao Uehara's work also contributed to discussions of forest therapy in health, rehabilitation and education.

These developments should not be reduced to the achievements of only one person or institution.

Giving credit is not simply about deciding who was first. It is about recognising how different contributions helped the field develop.
11.4 · Cultural Exchange or Appropriation?

Teaching Shinrin-Yoku outside Japan is not inherently an act of cultural appropriation.

Cultural exchange and international scientific collaboration can be valuable.

Concerns arise when Japanese traditions are misrepresented, cultural symbols are used without context, or organisations claim authority they do not possess.

Including a Japanese cultural practice within a training programme should involve appropriate understanding, acknowledgement and collaboration.

Living in Japan or studying Japanese practices does not automatically make a person an authority on every aspect of Japanese culture.

I believe respect requires humility, historical accuracy and recognition of local contributors.

Question 12 · Ecological Responsibility

Can Forest Therapy Harm the Nature It Celebrates?

How should guides evaluate short-term and long-term benefits and harms for participants, themselves and the forest?

12.1 · The Ethical Dilemma of Professional Guiding

Many guides enter this profession because they value nature and wish to share it with others.

Yet good intentions do not guarantee ecological sustainability.

Repeated sessions may affect vegetation, soil, wildlife or sensitive habitats.

A forest retreat may provide meaningful educational experiences while introducing environmental costs associated with travel and visitor activity.

The important questions are who benefits, who may experience harm, and over what period.

We should distinguish immediate participant satisfaction from longer-term ecological outcomes.

12.2 · Hedonic and Eudaimonic Wellbeing

In our training, we examine hedonic and eudaimonic dimensions of wellbeing.

Hedonic wellbeing concerns experiences such as pleasure, comfort, satisfaction and positive emotions.

Eudaimonic wellbeing involves meaning, purpose, values and personal development.

A participant may leave a session feeling relaxed without developing any lasting change in their relationship with nature.

Another may encounter an uncomfortable ecological question that becomes meaningful over time.

Neither experience automatically produces ecological protection.

Human psychological wellbeing and ecological wellbeing must therefore be examined as different outcomes.

12.3 · TMT® Wellbeing Circle of Influence

The TMT® Wellbeing Circle of Influence considers three interconnected dimensions of guided practice.

The guide: professional preparation, competence, personal wellbeing and ethical boundaries.

The participants: autonomy, dignity, accessibility, physical and emotional safety.

The forest: ecological integrity, biodiversity, habitat protection and resilience.

These dimensions interact, but their needs are not identical.

An enjoyable experience for participants may still place pressure on a fragile habitat.

A decision that protects the ecosystem may require changing the planned activity.

Professional judgment involves recognising these possibilities and making responsible decisions.

12.4 · Benefits and Harms Across Time

The following table considers potential benefits and harms over short and long timescales.

Dimension Short-term benefits Short-term harms Long-term benefits Long-term harms
Participants Rest, enjoyment, sensory contact, social connection Fatigue, distress, injury, financial cost Familiarity, independent nature engagement, meaning and possible care Dependency, repeated costs, unrealistic expectations
Guide Income, professional satisfaction, learning Physical fatigue, emotional demands, operational costs Professional development, sustainable livelihood, ecological understanding Burnout, commercial pressure, conflicts with professional values
Forest Possible monitoring or site stewardship when planned Trampling, soil damage, disturbance to organisms Possible conservation partnerships and habitat protection Erosion, habitat loss, cumulative visitor pressure
Local community Employment, educational exchange, local income Congestion, noise, additional resource use Partnerships, cultural recognition, support for conservation Unequal benefits, restricted access, pressure on local places

These are potential outcomes, not guaranteed effects. Their relevance depends on the site, activities, participants and management conditions.

A positive human experience does not automatically establish a positive environmental outcome.
12.5 · Environmental Risk Assessment and Co-Responsibility

Ecological responsibility begins before the session.

The guide should become familiar with the site, examine the route, consider ecological sensitivity and assess foreseeable impacts.

Invitations involving leaving paths, touching vegetation or collecting natural objects deserve particular attention.

Participants also have responsibility through their choices and behaviour.

But co-responsibility does not mean identical professional accountability.

The guide remains responsible for appropriate site selection, preparation, information, boundaries and adaptation.

Emotional attachment to nature may encourage ecological care, but that relationship should not be assumed.

Environmental responsibility must also be demonstrated through actual decisions and behaviour.

Question 13 · Nature and Human Experience

Why Do We Assume Nature Is Always Good for Us?

Nature contains beauty and restoration, but also danger, discomfort, uncertainty and ecological processes beyond human control.

13.1 · The Idealisation of Natural Environments

I do not believe nature is always beneficial in the way popular wellbeing messages suggest.

Some guides idealise forests because their own experiences have been deeply meaningful.

Yet personal experiences cannot be generalised to every participant.

Forests include ecological processes such as growth, competition, decomposition and disturbance.

They may also involve insects, allergens, dangerous weather, uneven terrain and physical discomfort.

Nature does not exist to guarantee human comfort.

13.2 · Human Evolution and Changing Expectations

Human beings evolved within natural environments, but this does not mean those environments were always comfortable.

Earlier human societies encountered natural conditions through survival, labour, observation and adaptation.

Modernisation changed many people's everyday experiences of comfort, safety and the environment.

Someone familiar with urban surroundings may experience a forest as unpredictable.

A person accustomed to outdoor environments may respond differently.

We should not romanticise earlier human life or assume that people from the past were necessarily more connected.

Familiarity, knowledge, cultural circumstances and individual experience all shape our responses.

13.3 · Forest Atmospheres and Chemical Complexity

Forest environments are chemically and biologically dynamic.

Plants release volatile organic compounds involved in ecological interactions.

Their concentrations and compositions vary according to species, temperature and environmental conditions.

We should not assume that every plant-derived substance benefits human health.

The biological response depends on the compound, concentration, exposure and individual circumstances.

Scientific evidence about isolated substances does not automatically describe the effects of ordinary forest air.

Natural does not automatically mean harmless. The forest atmosphere is complex, and its effects require careful scientific investigation.
13.4 · Physical and Emotional Risk Assessment

At The Mindful Tourist®, students learn to assess both physical and emotional risks.

Site assessment involves visiting the location, walking intended paths, examining terrain and considering environmental conditions.

The guide must also consider participant needs, limitations and the potential risks of individual invitations.

A session plan should remain adaptable.

Weather, group responses or unexpected circumstances may require changes.

Risk assessment does not eliminate all uncertainty.

It supports more responsible decisions within an unpredictable environment.

13.5 · Must Every Nature Experience Be Pleasant?

Not every meaningful encounter with nature involves pleasure.

Someone may experience boredom, sadness, uncertainty or physical tiredness.

These responses do not automatically mean that the experience has failed.

But we should not describe discomfort as evidence of healing.

A guide should distinguish ordinary discomfort from inappropriate or potentially harmful conditions.

Participant autonomy, appropriate preparation and professional boundaries remain essential.

Nature does not need to be comfortable to be meaningful. But discomfort does not become therapeutic simply because it occurs in nature.
Question 14 · Nature Connectedness

If We Are Already Part of Nature, What Does It Mean to Reconnect?

Perhaps reconnection is less about restoring a biological relationship that has disappeared and more about recognising one that continues.

14.1 · The Meaning of Reconnect

I often pause when I encounter the expression "reconnect with nature."

The English prefix re- suggests doing something again or returning to something.

This raises a question: what exactly was lost?

Human beings remain biological organisms embedded within ecological systems.

We depend upon air, water, food, microorganisms and environmental processes.

That dependence does not disappear when we move into cities.

Perhaps reconnection concerns a change in experience or awareness rather than the restoration of a literally lost biological relationship.

14.2 · Japanese Language and the Idea of Connection

The Japanese word tsunagari (つながり) refers to connection or relationship.

Shizen to no tsunagari (自然とのつながり) can describe a connection with nature.

Reconnection can be expressed in different ways depending on context.

These linguistic distinctions invite reflection, but should not be treated as evidence of one universal Japanese philosophy.

I also consider the expression omoidasu (思い出す), meaning to remember or recall.

Perhaps reconnecting is sometimes closer to remembering or recognising a relationship than establishing one that never existed.

This is my philosophical interpretation, not a literal linguistic equation.

14.3 · Phenomenology: What Does Disconnection Feel Like?

Rather than assume someone is disconnected from nature, perhaps we should begin by asking what that means in their experience.

Do they feel unfamiliar with forests?

Do they lack access to green spaces?

Do they feel emotionally indifferent toward natural environments?

Or do they believe that humans exist separately from nature?

These are different experiences.

Someone may live near a forest without feeling connected to it.

Another person may feel deeply connected with a particular tree in an urban garden.

Being part of nature and experiencing oneself as part of nature are not necessarily the same thing.
14.4 · Agriculture, Industrialisation and Urbanisation

Agricultural development, industrialisation and urbanisation have transformed many relationships between human beings and environments.

However, these changes should not be described as one simple history of losing nature.

Agriculture also involves direct ecological knowledge and relationships with land.

Modern development has contributed to improvements in sanitation, healthcare, education and safety.

At the same time, many people have become less directly involved in ecological processes supporting everyday life.

Our relationship with natural environments has changed.

But this does not mean everyone has experienced the same degree or form of psychological disconnection.

14.5 · The Many Pathways to Nature Connectedness

People develop relationships with nature in many ways.

Some begin through scientific curiosity.

Others through beauty, memory, spiritual traditions, direct sensory experience or practical environmental care.

Someone may feel connected to nature through a childhood landscape or family history.

Another may develop a relationship through gardening or ecological research.

These experiences should not be ranked simply according to their emotional intensity.

Practical, intellectual, aesthetic and emotional forms of engagement may all be meaningful.

We should also distinguish nature contact from nature connectedness.

Repeated contact may support familiarity, but it does not guarantee emotional attachment or ecological action.

14.6 · From Reconnection to Recognition

Perhaps reconnection remains a useful expression in everyday language.

But I find the idea of recognition increasingly meaningful.

The ecological relationship continues whether we consciously notice it or not.

What may change is our attention, understanding, identity and behaviour.

Someone may begin by seeking relaxation.

Another may begin with curiosity or environmental education.

Over time, these experiences may develop into familiarity, meaning or care.

But this progression is not guaranteed or identical for everyone.

The role of education is to create opportunities for development without prescribing what every participant must experience.

Perhaps our task is not to reconnect human beings with something from which they were biologically separated, but to recognise more consciously the relationships through which we have always existed.

Are We Learning to Be with Nature, or Still Organising Nature Around Ourselves?

These four questions remind us that our professional relationship with nature requires more than good intentions.

Historical accuracy matters. Cultural recognition matters. Environmental responsibility matters. And so does the way we understand our place within the living world.

We can acknowledge Japan's contributions to Shinrin-Yoku without claiming that human relationships with forests began there.

We can support human wellbeing while examining the ecological consequences of our activities.

We can appreciate nature's therapeutic potential without assuming that every natural experience is safe or pleasant.

And we can support nature connectedness without prescribing one correct way of experiencing it.

Nature existed before we named it, studied it or developed professional methods for experiencing it. Perhaps what changes is not the existence of our connection, but how consciously we recognise and live it.

With gratitude,

Milena A. Guziak, MChem, PhDEng, MScPsy
Founder, The Mindful Tourist®
Founder, Shinrin-Yoku Association

The Mindful Tourist® · Q&A Follow-up Part 5

Research & Further Reading

Nature, Culture and Ethics

Explore the publications, historical sources and scientific studies informing our discussion of Questions 11–14.

Research by Milena A. Guziak is presented separately from external scientific and historical sources.

QUESTION 11 · CULTURAL HISTORY

Japanese Origins of Shinrin-Yoku

Historical origins, the 1982 Japanese Forestry Agency initiative, Shinto, sacred forests and scientific contributions to the field.

Research by Milena A. Guziak

From Shinrin-Yoku (Forest Bathing) to Forest Therapy Guziak, M. A. (2025) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

Historical development of Shinrin-Yoku and the evolution of Japanese forest therapy terminology.

Honoring Tradition, Science, and the Future Guziak, M. A. (2025) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

Japanese scientific contributions, cultural plurality and the development of international nature-based education.

External Historical Sources

Forest Bathing (森林浴) Japanese Forestry Agency · Official source

Japanese-language overview, including the Forestry Agency's introduction of Shinrin-Yoku in 1982.

Miyazaki Yoshifumi Explores the Healing Power of the Forest Nippon.com · Interview · 2018

Professor Miyazaki discusses the history of Shinrin-Yoku and the development of physiological forest research.

What Are Shrine Groves? Japan Tourism Agency · 2019

An introduction to chinju no mori, sacred shrine groves and their religious and historical context.

QUESTION 12 · ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS

Can Forest Therapy Harm Nature?

Ecological consequences of guided activities, short- and long-term impacts, professional responsibility and the TMT® Wellbeing Circle of Influence.

Research by Milena A. Guziak

When Does Nature Become Therapy? Guziak, M. A. (2026) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

Therapeutic agency, ecological responsibility, professional guidance and commercialisation.

Establishing Ethical Standards and Best Practices Guziak, M. A. (2025) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

Ethical guiding responsibilities, environmental protection, professional competence and participant wellbeing.

SYA Code of Ethical Conduct Shinrin-Yoku Association · 2026 framework

Professional principles covering ecological responsibility, physical and emotional safety and ethical session design.

External Scientific Research

Impacts of Informal Trails on Vegetation and Soils Barros, Gonnet & Pickering (2013)

Research from Aconcagua Provincial Park, Argentina, examining impacts of recreational trails on vegetation and soil.

DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2013.04.030

Meta-analysis of Human Connection to Nature and Proenvironmental Behavior Whitburn, Linklater & Abrahamse (2020)

Examines the relationship between nature connectedness and pro-environmental behaviour. Association does not establish automatic behavioural change.

DOI: 10.1111/cobi.13381

QUESTION 13 · REALITY OF NATURE

Nature, Safety and Unpredictability

Beyond the idealisation of nature: ecological complexity, forest chemistry, environmental hazards and responsible session preparation.

Research by Milena A. Guziak

Phytoncides and Forest Volatile Organic Compounds Guziak, M. A. (2024) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

Ecological foundations, chemical diversity, environmental variation and limitations of health claims concerning forest atmospheres.

Comprehensive Assessment and Optimization of Invitations Guziak, M. A. (2025) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

Methodology for critically examining invitation design, participant needs, safety and facilitation decisions.

Professional Standards and Context

Physical and Emotional Risk Assessment Shinrin-Yoku Association · Code of Conduct

Read the sections addressing site assessment, environmental conditions, participant safety, emotional risks and dynamic professional judgment.

Recreational Impact in Sensitive Mountain Environments Barros, Gonnet & Pickering (2013)

Evidence that environmental vulnerability can vary according to the site, vegetation and characteristics of recreational use.

QUESTION 14 · NATURE CONNECTEDNESS

From Reconnection to Recognition

Nature contact and nature connectedness, the experience of disconnection, different pathways of engagement, and recognition of our ecological belonging.

Research by Milena A. Guziak

Spending Time in the Forest: Modalities of Engagement, Connection and Care Guziak, M. A. (2026) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

A conceptual examination of different ways of engaging with forests, including continuity, meaning and care.

Nature Connection, Emotion Regulation and Mindful Attention Awareness Guziak, M. A. (2025) · Shinrin-Yoku Journal

Research examining relationships among nature connectedness, emotional regulation and mindful attention.

External Scientific Research

Beyond Knowing Nature: Pathways to Nature Connection Lumber, Richardson & Sheffield (2017)

Explores contact, emotion, compassion, meaning and beauty as pathways associated with nature connectedness.

DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0177186

Human Connection to Nature and Proenvironmental Behavior Whitburn, Linklater & Abrahamse (2020)

Examines the relationship between nature connection and environmental behaviour, including the limitations of interpreting associations.

Sources are provided for further reading and critical examination. Some journal publications may require membership access to the complete text.

The Mindful Tourist®

Nature-Based Intervention, Mindfulness & Wellbeing.

Research and reflections by
Milena A. Guziak, MChem, PhDEng, MScPsy

www.themindfultourist.net

Author: Milena A. Guziak, PhD Founder, The Mindful Tourist & Shinrin-Yoku Association

Milena A. Guziak photographed outdoors among trees
Milena A. Guziak · Founder of The Mindful Tourist®

A little about the person behind the work

Meet Milena A. Guziak

MChem · PhD Eng · MSc Psychology

Founder of The Mindful Tourist® and the Shinrin-Yoku Association, Milena brings together a background in chemistry, applied physics and psychology with years of experience in Japan, nature connection, Shinrin-Yoku, mindfulness, meditation and reflective writing.

Her journey has not followed one straight path. What once appeared to be separate interests has gradually revealed connections — between scientific inquiry, direct experience, the natural world and the changing experience of being human.

The Mindful Tourist is not simply about travelling to new places. It is about travelling through life with curiosity, attention and a willingness to keep learning.
error: Content is protected !!
Text size
100%
New Research Publication ✦ When Does Nature Become Therapy? ✦ Shinrin-Yoku · Forest Bathing · Forest Therapy ✦ Read the Scientific Article → ✦
Member Login Login