The Mindful Tourist Nature-Based Intervention, Mindfulness & Wellbeing
The Mindful Tourist

We Are Updating Our Website

We are currently updating The Mindful Tourist website, including pages, articles and resources dating back to 2021.

Bringing everything up to date will take some time. During this process, certain pages and links may not yet work as expected.

We sincerely apologise for any inconvenience. You are warmly invited to continue exploring the website and the content already available.

Thank you for your patience and understanding.

Follow-up Q&A with Milena — Part 4: Does Forest Therapy Really Work, and Can It Sometimes Cause Harm?

The Mindful Tourist® · Q&A with Milena

Science, Evidence
& Therapeutic Claims

Follow-up Part 4 · Questions 7–10

Shinrin-Yoku · Forest Bathing · Forest Therapy

Milena A. Guziak, MChem, PhDEng, MScPsy

Does forest therapy actually work? Can someone leave a forest therapy session feeling worse? Can a guide unintentionally cause harm?

And what happens when forest therapy is considered in relation to depression, anxiety or trauma?

These questions invite us to examine the relationship between scientific evidence, individual experience, environmental conditions and professional responsibility.

As someone with a background in chemistry, applied physics and psychology, I value scientific research. Yet direct human experience is rarely explained through one variable alone.

The participant, forest, activity, guide and social context may all contribute to what unfolds.

Choose one of the four questions below and explore the different aspects of my responses.

Question 07 · Science and Evidence

Does Forest Therapy Actually Work, or Do People Simply Feel Better Because They Expect To?

How can we distinguish the effects of forest exposure from movement, rest, social interaction and psychological expectations?

7.1 · It Does, and It Doesn't — What Does "Work" Mean?

My first response may sound contradictory, but it depends upon what we mean by the word work.

Are we asking whether a forest visit reduces perceived stress, changes cortisol, supports attention, improves mood, influences clinical symptoms, or strengthens nature connectedness?

These are different outcomes. Scientific evidence supporting one does not automatically establish effectiveness for another.

A person may enter a forest to walk, cycle, rest, take photographs or join a structured Shinrin-Yoku session.

In all these situations, the individual encounters an environment with particular biological, chemical, physical and sensory characteristics.

The forest continues functioning regardless of whether the person intends to experience something therapeutic.

But environmental exposure does not guarantee a beneficial physiological or psychological outcome.

An environment may influence us without our conscious intention, but that does not mean every influence is therapeutic.
7.2 · The Forest, Movement, Rest and Social Interaction

Imagine two people walking for the same length of time.

One walks through a forest, while the other walks through a city.

Both may receive benefits associated with physical movement and temporary relief from daily responsibilities.

However, their environments differ in visual patterns, sounds, temperature, air quality, vegetation and other characteristics.

How can we distinguish which element contributes to a particular outcome?

Researchers may compare forest and urban conditions while attempting to match activity, duration and other variables.

Yet even carefully designed studies may struggle to isolate every environmental influence.

Social interaction adds another layer. A supportive friend may contribute to a meaningful experience.

But an uncomfortable social encounter may instead increase stress.

The forest, physical activity, social circumstances and personal expectations can interact.

This is why I prefer to examine the experience as a complex interaction rather than attribute every change to one therapeutic agent.

7.3 · What If Two Friends Have an Argument in the Forest?

Consider two friends visiting a forest together.

During their walk, they disagree, and the conversation becomes emotionally intense.

Their stress responses may become activated. Heart rate may increase, attention may narrow, and their emotional states may change.

Yet the forest remains present.

Does the surrounding environment prevent the stress response? Not necessarily.

Could it influence the magnitude or duration of that response? Possibly.

But to investigate this, we would need to consider their physiological condition before entering the forest, what happened during the disagreement, and how they recovered afterwards.

Cortisol is particularly interesting because its concentration changes naturally throughout the day.

It is also influenced by sleep, activity, illness, medication and numerous other factors.

A lower cortisol value after a forest visit does not automatically prove that the forest caused the reduction.

Measuring a change tells us that something changed. It does not necessarily explain what caused that change.
7.4 · Expectations, Placebo and Subjective Experience

We should distinguish expectations from placebo effects and from broader placebo responses.

Expectations concern what people anticipate before an experience.

Someone attending forest therapy may expect to feel peaceful because of previous experiences, advertising or information from the guide.

These expectations may influence perception, attention and reporting.

Placebo effects involve psychological mechanisms associated with the treatment context, including expectation and learning.

Broader placebo responses may also include natural fluctuations, regression toward the mean and other influences.

Therefore, we cannot conclude that a participant's improvement is simply a placebo effect because they expected to feel better.

Nor should expectations be dismissed as imaginary. Psychological processes are part of human biological experience.

The challenge is to understand their contribution without assuming they explain every outcome.

7.5 · Guided versus Independent Forest Experiences

A guided Shinrin-Yoku session introduces elements that may not be present in an independent visit.

These include structured invitations, professional preparation, group facilitation, communication, pacing and participant expectations.

But professional guidance does not automatically establish a more therapeutic experience.

Someone exploring independently may experience restoration, emotional connection or meaningful personal reflection.

Conversely, a guided group may include social dynamics that some participants find uncomfortable.

The research question is not simply whether guided forest therapy works.

It is whether guidance contributes additional benefits, under what conditions, and for which people.

This distinction is important when assessing professional claims and the value of guided services.

7.6 · What Can We Conclude from the Evidence?

Scientific reviews report promising psychological and physiological outcomes associated with forest exposure and certain structured forest-based interventions.

Yet study quality, heterogeneity, participant expectations, incomplete blinding and limited long-term follow-up remain important concerns.

We should therefore be careful about promising particular outcomes.

A forest experience may support stress reduction, attention, restoration or nature connectedness.

But it may also be neutral or uncomfortable for a particular person under particular circumstances.

The appropriate conclusion is not that forest therapy never works, nor that it always works.

Rather, it has potential benefits that must be interpreted in relation to the individual, environment, activity and evidence available.

What happens, for whom, under which conditions, compared with what, and with what degree of scientific confidence?
Question 08 · Subjective Experience

If Someone Leaves a Forest Therapy Session Feeling Worse, Has It Failed?

Must a beneficial experience always feel pleasant? What happens when sadness, fatigue, discomfort or difficult memories emerge?

8.1 · What Does "Feeling Worse" Actually Mean?

Before determining whether the session has failed, we should ask what the participant means by feeling worse.

Do they feel sad, anxious, angry, disappointed, sleepy, exhausted or emotionally overwhelmed?

These experiences are not equivalent.

Someone may become aware of sadness that existed before the session.

Another person may become physically tired from walking or uncomfortable because of weather conditions.

Another may dislike a particular invitation or group interaction.

We should clarify the nature of the experience before attempting to interpret it.

Feeling worse is a subjective description, not a diagnosis or a scientific explanation.
8.2 · Why Might Difficult Emotions Emerge?

Everyday life often involves continuous activity, conversation, tasks and external stimulation.

A forest session may introduce a different rhythm.

Movement slows, silence increases and attention may turn toward sensory or inner experience.

Under these circumstances, previously unnoticed feelings may become more apparent.

Perhaps the person becomes aware of sadness, fatigue or an unresolved personal concern.

Perhaps a particular sound or landscape evokes a memory.

But this is only one possible explanation.

Distress may also emerge because the person feels unsafe, uncomfortable or pressured by the activity.

We should not automatically interpret emotional discomfort as evidence of healing.

8.3 · Nervous-System Responses and Sleepiness

The autonomic nervous system participates in physiological regulation during rest, activity, stress and recovery.

Its sympathetic and parasympathetic divisions are not simply opposite switches controlling stress and relaxation.

Their functions are complex, interconnected and dependent upon physiological context.

Consider someone who finishes a guided session feeling sleepy.

Does this mean the session had a positive relaxing effect?

Perhaps, but we cannot conclude that from sleepiness alone.

The person may have been sleep-deprived, physically tired, affected by warm weather, or experiencing reduced stimulation.

Some relaxation-related changes may also be associated with feelings of drowsiness.

But a subjective report cannot establish a particular autonomic state without appropriate evidence.

One participant may welcome feeling sleepy, while another interprets the same sensation as unpleasant.

8.4 · Co-Creation, Co-Being and Co-Responsibility

In my research, I explore co-creation, co-responsibility and co-being as conceptual principles for understanding guided experiences.

Co-creation recognises that the experience does not arise solely through the actions of a guide.

The participant brings personal history, expectations, emotions and decisions.

The forest contributes through its changing environmental and sensory conditions.

The guide contributes through preparation, facilitation, communication and professional responsibility.

Co-being invites us to consider the experience of sharing a natural environment without constantly controlling its meaning.

Co-responsibility recognises participant agency while preserving the professional accountability of the guide.

Shared participation does not mean that the participant becomes responsible for failures of professional safeguarding.

8.5 · When Is Discomfort a Concern?

A session does not automatically fail because a participant feels sadness or other difficult emotions.

However, discomfort should never be romanticised as evidence of therapeutic progress.

We should examine the circumstances.

Was the invitation appropriate? Was consent clear? Did the participant feel free to decline?

Did the guide recognise signs of discomfort?

Was the person supported within appropriate professional boundaries?

If distress arose because of an avoidable guiding error, the quality and safety of facilitation require attention.

If significant psychological distress persists, appropriate healthcare support may be needed.

An unpleasant experience is not automatically a failure. But an unpleasant experience is not automatically healing either.
Question 09 · Safety and Professional Ethics

Can a Forest Therapy Guide Unintentionally Cause Psychological Harm?

Where does sensitive facilitation end and inappropriate psychological intervention begin?

9.1 · Good Intentions Are Not Enough

Yes, a guide may unintentionally contribute to psychological harm.

A guide may genuinely care about participants and believe strongly in Shinrin-Yoku.

They may also have experienced profound personal benefits from forest environments.

But good intentions do not guarantee that every professional decision will be appropriate.

This is precisely why our training emphasises professional boundaries, informed consent, physical and emotional risk assessment, and reflection on guiding protocols.

A guide should not assume that an invitation is safe simply because it appears gentle or mindfulness-oriented.

9.2 · Why Invitations Are Not Psychologically Neutral

Consider a simple invitation: close your eyes and follow your breathing.

For some participants, this may feel calming.

For others, closing their eyes outdoors may increase vulnerability or discomfort.

Attention directed toward bodily sensations may also be uncomfortable for someone experiencing anxiety.

Similarly, a period of prolonged silence may encourage reflection for one person and unwanted distress for another.

Therefore, the possible effects of an invitation depend not only on its wording, but also on participant needs, environmental conditions and how it is facilitated.

Participants should be free to adapt, decline or discontinue an invitation without pressure.

9.3 · Where Facilitation Ends and Psychotherapy Begins

A Shinrin-Yoku Guide may provide appropriate opportunities for reflection, sensory engagement and meaningful nature connection.

But this is not equivalent to providing psychotherapy.

If a participant begins crying, the guide may acknowledge their experience, offer space, present alternatives or ask whether they would prefer to stop.

The guide should not automatically investigate childhood memories, attempt to process trauma or interpret the experience as psychological healing.

Without appropriate clinical qualifications, the guide should not diagnose or treat psychological conditions.

Professional sensitivity also involves recognising when another qualified professional is needed.

Respecting someone's emotions does not require claiming authority over what those emotions mean.
9.4 · Assessing Each Invitation and Session Protocol

This question connects directly with my research on the comprehensive assessment and optimisation of Shinrin-Yoku invitations.

In TMT® training, students examine session design rather than merely reproduce a collection of activities.

Before facilitating, the guide considers the participant group, environmental conditions, activity structure and foreseeable risks.

Risk assessment includes physical hazards such as terrain, weather and accessibility, as well as emotional considerations.

Students also prepare session plans and reflect upon their practical guiding experience through SYA Assessment Markers.

This process helps connect preparation, actual facilitation and reflective learning.

An invitation that worked well with one group may need substantial adaptation for another.

9.5 · The TMT® Scaffolded Model of Engagement

The TMT® Scaffolded Model of Engagement offers one framework for balancing structure and freedom.

It introduces six Degrees of Freedom across three broad stages:

Sensory Anchoring (DoF 1–2)
More structured invitations may support orientation, clarity and confidence.

Guided Exploration (DoF 3–4)
Participants are offered more opportunities for curiosity, interpretation and personal choice.

Full Autonomy (DoF 5–6)
More open-ended invitations may support self-directed engagement.

However, the model is not a rigid progression.

Participants may need more or less structure depending on their readiness and circumstances.

The guide remains responsible for monitoring conditions and adapting the experience.

Structure should support freedom. Freedom should not be introduced without regard for safety, readiness and individual needs.
9.6 · The Professional Value of Recognising Our Limits

A guide cannot fully predict how every participant will respond to an invitation.

Nor can they know the meaning of every emotional experience.

Sometimes the most responsible response is to acknowledge uncertainty.

The guide may recognise that a situation requires support beyond their professional competence.

They may need to stop an activity, modify the protocol, document an incident or recommend appropriate professional assistance.

This is not a failure of professional identity.

It demonstrates ethical awareness and recognition of the limits of guiding.

Professional competence includes knowing what we do not know, and when we should not attempt to intervene.
Question 10 · Mental Health and Clinical Care

Should Forest Therapy Be Recommended for Depression, Anxiety or Trauma?

What does the research support, and where is the boundary between general wellbeing activities and clinical intervention?

10.1 · Everyday Experiences versus Clinical Conditions

My answer is yes, forest-based experiences may be valuable.

But we need to clarify what is being recommended, to whom, and by which professional.

Most human beings experience sadness, anxiety, uncertainty or emotionally difficult events during their lives.

These experiences are not automatically equivalent to clinical diagnoses.

Clinical depressive and anxiety disorders involve diagnostic considerations such as symptoms, duration, severity and effects on functioning.

The term trauma is also used in everyday language and within formal clinical frameworks.

The popular expressions small-t trauma and big-T trauma are not formal diagnoses.

Guides should recognise these distinctions without attempting to diagnose participants.

10.2 · What Does Research Say About Depression and Anxiety?

Scientific reviews report potentially beneficial effects of some forest-based interventions on depressive symptoms, anxiety and psychological stress.

However, research findings depend on study design, participant characteristics, intervention structure and comparison conditions.

Methodological limitations, incomplete blinding, heterogeneity and limited long-term follow-up must be considered.

A person reporting improved mood after a forest experience does not necessarily demonstrate that a clinical disorder has been treated.

Similarly, improvements during an intervention do not always establish that the intervention itself caused the change.

We therefore need to distinguish general wellbeing benefits from clinical treatment claims.

10.3 · What About PTSD and Trauma-Related Difficulties?

Nature-based interventions have also been investigated in relation to post-traumatic stress symptoms.

Some studies report improvements, but the current evidence remains insufficient to establish nature therapy as a replacement for recommended trauma-focused care.

It is also important to recognise that natural environments are not universally experienced as safe or relaxing.

For some individuals, unfamiliar sounds, isolation or unpredictability may contribute to discomfort.

Another person may feel more comfortable in a garden than in an enclosed room.

Neither response should be assumed to be universal.

The suitability of a particular activity or environment depends upon the person and their circumstances.

10.4 · Can a Psychotherapist Work Outdoors?

Yes, an appropriately qualified psychotherapist may conduct suitable clinical interventions in natural environments.

The forest, garden or park then becomes the setting in which clinical work takes place.

However, the therapist's responsibilities remain applicable.

Clinical assessment, informed consent, confidentiality, professional boundaries and safeguarding still matter.

The practitioner must also possess appropriate competence for working in that environment.

A psychotherapist does not necessarily need to be certified as a Shinrin-Yoku Guide simply to provide psychotherapy outdoors.

Conversely, Shinrin-Yoku Guide certification does not authorise an unqualified person to provide psychotherapy.

The environment may change, but professional responsibilities do not disappear.
10.5 · Forests, Healing Gardens and Nature-Based Interventions

Nature-based interventions are not limited to forests.

They may involve gardens, parks, horticultural activities, green spaces, outdoor psychotherapy or structured rehabilitation.

These approaches differ in objectives, participant groups, professional requirements and available evidence.

A healing garden in a hospital is not necessarily the same as a therapeutic horticulture programme.

An independent forest walk is not equivalent to a structured clinical intervention.

And a guided Shinrin-Yoku session does not automatically become psychotherapy because a participant experiences emotional change.

Understanding these differences can help us communicate therapeutic claims more responsibly.

10.6 · Evidence, Collaboration and Scope of Practice

The evidence required to recommend a gentle nature walk for general wellbeing is not necessarily the same as the evidence needed to claim that a programme treats a diagnosed condition.

Stronger clinical claims require appropriately rigorous research, relevant outcome measures, suitable comparisons and careful monitoring of risks.

Professional collaboration may be particularly valuable.

A psychotherapist may bring clinical expertise.

A Shinrin-Yoku Guide may contribute knowledge of session facilitation, environmental assessment and participant-centred nature engagement.

Other professionals may contribute expertise in occupational therapy, rehabilitation, horticulture or environmental education.

Collaboration should clarify responsibilities rather than blur professional boundaries.

A diagnosis should not automatically exclude someone from an ordinary nature experience.

However, suitability and safety should always be considered in relation to individual needs.

Nature may contribute to wellbeing without replacing clinical treatment. A forest can support a therapeutic encounter without making every guide a therapist.

Understanding the Experience Without Reducing It to One Cause

After examining these four questions, I return to something that has increasingly occupied my thoughts.

We often try to explain complex experiences by identifying one cause.

Was it the forest? Was it the guide? Was it physical movement? Was it expectation? Was it social interaction?

Scientific research often requires us to isolate variables. This is necessary and valuable.

But human experience does not necessarily unfold through isolated variables.

The participant brings their body, history, emotions, expectations and decisions.

The forest brings its changing ecological and environmental conditions.

The guide contributes through preparation, communication, facilitation and professional responsibility.

Other participants may also influence what unfolds.

I increasingly approach Shinrin-Yoku through the conceptual principles of co-creation, co-responsibility and co-being.

These principles do not replace scientific evidence, nor do they establish clinical efficacy.

Rather, they invite us to recognise the complexity of the encounter.

What happens when a particular human being encounters a particular natural environment, under particular conditions, and how responsibly do we understand, facilitate and evaluate that experience?

With gratitude,

Milena A. Guziak, MChem, PhDEng, MScPsy
Founder, The Mindful Tourist®
Founder, Shinrin-Yoku Association

Research & Further Reading

Explore related publications by Milena A. Guziak in the Shinrin-Yoku Journal.

SHINRIN-YOKU JOURNAL · 2023

Physiological Markers of Wellbeing

Cortisol, autonomic responses, inflammatory processes and interpretation of physiological changes.

Explore Publication →
SHINRIN-YOKU JOURNAL · 2023

Nature and Human Well-Being

Environmental psychology, restoration theories, nature connectedness and wellbeing.

Explore Publication →
SHINRIN-YOKU JOURNAL · 2024

Phytoncides and Forest VOCs

Ecological functions, chemical diversity and possible relevance to human health.

Explore Publication →
SHINRIN-YOKU JOURNAL · 2025

Nature Connection and Emotion Regulation

Relationships between nature connectedness, emotional regulation and mindful attention awareness.

Explore Publication →
SHINRIN-YOKU JOURNAL · 2025

Assessment and Optimization of Invitations

Examining invitation structure, risks, participant experience and guiding protocols.

Explore Publication →
SHINRIN-YOKU JOURNAL · 2023

Scaffolded Model of Engagement

Participant-centred facilitation, gradual release and Degrees of Freedom 1–6.

Explore Publication →
SHINRIN-YOKU JOURNAL · 2026

When Does Nature Become Therapy?

Therapeutic experience, participant agency, professional responsibilities and commercialisation.

Explore Publication →

Some journal articles require membership access for full text.

Author: Milena A. Guziak, PhD Founder, The Mindful Tourist & Shinrin-Yoku Association

Milena A. Guziak photographed outdoors among trees
Milena A. Guziak · Founder of The Mindful Tourist®

A little about the person behind the work

Meet Milena A. Guziak

MChem · PhD Eng · MSc Psychology

Founder of The Mindful Tourist® and the Shinrin-Yoku Association, Milena brings together a background in chemistry, applied physics and psychology with years of experience in Japan, nature connection, Shinrin-Yoku, mindfulness, meditation and reflective writing.

Her journey has not followed one straight path. What once appeared to be separate interests has gradually revealed connections — between scientific inquiry, direct experience, the natural world and the changing experience of being human.

The Mindful Tourist is not simply about travelling to new places. It is about travelling through life with curiosity, attention and a willingness to keep learning.
error: Content is protected !!
Text size
100%
New Research Publication ✦ When Does Nature Become Therapy? ✦ Shinrin-Yoku · Forest Bathing · Forest Therapy ✦ Read the Scientific Article → ✦
Member Login Login